Jun 23

Spawning Report: Ancistrus sp. 'Santa Cruz Forest Preserve'


Edited: Jun 23


Ancistrus sp. ‘Santa Cruz Forest Preserve’ Breeding Report

Submitted by Patchin Crandall Curtis


The male and female parent Ancistrus were collected by Devon Graham and Patchin Curtis on Thursday, 8/13/2015 in the Santa Cruz Forest Preserve. We hiked out to the back property line to fish in a couple of small streams or brooks that feed into the Rio Mazan.

Latitude: S03 35' 450" Longitude: W072 28' 325" Water temperature: 77.5 Hardness: 6-7 ppm.


We saw lots of Flag Tetras, Blue Tetras, Red-eye Tetras, Darter Tetras, Silver Hatchetfish, whiptail catfish, a few Apistogramma, and abundant Corydoras rabauti. Devon picked up a long, hollow piece of driftwood and the male and female bushy nose plecos popped out.

The Ancistrus pair were kept in a 50 gallon breeder tank for about a year with various tetras. The pair went to live with Jeanette and Andrew Blumhagen for the first half of 2017 while I was in Paris. When they came back home late summer 2017, they were put in a 38 gallon tank with a colony of Blue Emperor Tetras. The tank had a substrate of CaribSea Eco-Complete Red, 4 Cobalt pleco breeding caves (2 small and 2 large), and was planted with Bacopa caroliniana, Crytocoryne wendtii, and Echinodorus tenellus, and Echinodorus angustifolia ‘Vesuvius.’ The tank was also home to a sometimes alarming number of pond snails.


Tank water was maintained at 78o F with a neutral pH ranging from 6.9 to 7.6 and hardness of 4-6d GH and 2-4d KH.


The male chose one of the smaller caves for spawning. It didn’t seem physically possible for him to cram the female in there, but cram her in he did, and she had the scrapes to prove it. There were a few unsuccessful attempts at spawning with a large percentage of unfertilized eggs expelled from the cave by the male. In January 2018, Jeremy Basch noted that the female appeared to be very gravid. In February, 2018 Devon Graham stayed with me when he came to speak, and the male was sitting on eggs. Unfortunately, I learned the hard way that Blue Emperor Tetras do not make good dither fish. There are no fry they can’t eat, even baby plecos with ferocious spines to protect them. Once the first tetra figured out how to eat the baby Ancistrus, it was a massacre. There was nothing I could do at that point except leave the room and let nature takes its course. The next day, I removed the tetras from the tank.


By March, 2018 it was clear that the male was sitting on another batch of eggs. In April, fry started to appear in the tank. I never saw fry until they were a few millimeters long, and the egg sac was long gone. No special attempts were made to spread food around the tank for the fry due to fears of fouling the tank water. Instead, I placed ceramic disks of Repashy Soilent Green, or Community Plus, or Spawn ‘n Grow in a few regular places around the tank so the babies would know where they could go to find food. Some fry were great food foragers right from the start and would readily come scurrying over to where the food was placed. Other fry were skinny and inactive and poor foragers. They seemed to just wither up and disappear within a few days. After a couple of months, I had about 34 robust fry running around the tank which were then raised to juveniles.


Two lots of five each of the juveniles were sold at the JRAS Spring Fling on 3/16/2019, two lots were sold at the PVAS Spring All-Day Auction on 4/7/2019, and the last two lots at the NEC 44th Convention Auction on 4/14/2019.


Andrew Blumhagen is able to verify the spawn.


9/20/2017 Initial breeding setup before the massacre and removal of the Blue Emperor Tetras
9/20/2017 Mom posing for her close-up





5/14/2018 Dad posing for his close-up



4/7/2018 Babies are finally out of the cave and settled on the backside of a 3" diameter Repashy ceramic feeding disk


5/13/2018 A month later, they like hanging out with Mom


6/5/2018 Two months out of the cave enjoying some zuccini


6/27/2018 almost 3 months out of the cave hanging out on some Bacopa



Hello Patchin,


This is to confirm that you have been awarded 30 points for the successful spawning and rearing of your Ancistrus. These points may be revised downward in future pending reclassification of Ancistrus species into a different BAP category.




New Posts
  • Pethia padamya (Odessa Barb) Spawning Report Submitted by Patchin Crandall Curtis Background: Odessa Barbs are native to central Myanmar where they are found in ponds and streams at an altitude of 3000’. The fish first appeared in the hobby in the early 1970’s in Odessa, Ukraine from which it takes its common name. The species was formally described in 2008 by Kullander and Britz in the Bulletin of the European Ichthyology Society 2: 56-66. Colony: I purchased an initial colony of 10 fish from Invertebrates by MsJinkzd on 12/3/2017. As they grew out, it became apparent that the fish were all males. Rachel O’Leary confirmed that the entire shipment seemed to be males. I purchased an additional 6 fish from The Wet Spot on 3/1/2018 requesting all females but knowing that it’s virtually impossible to sex juveniles. As the fish grew to adulthood, 3 of the 6 proved to be females. The entire group was raised to adulthood in a 55g tank, and then moved into a community barb tank which they share with 6 Dawkinsia assimilis (Mascara Barbs) and 10 Barbodes dunkeri (Clown Barbs). It is a very active, inquisitive, and peaceful community. Tank Set-Up: The community of large barbs lives in a 180 g, unheated tank aquascaped with manzanita wood and stones. The substrate is CaribSea Peace River gravel. The only plants that can be grown with these fish are crinums, aponogeton, and Anubias. All others are devoured, but I’m not sure how much of this is the fault of the Odessa Barbs versus the other two species. Odessa Barbs do best within a subtropical temperature range of 68oF – 74oF. The water is relatively soft and neutral. Nitrates are generally kept in the range of 2.5 – 10 ppm. Running a surface skimmer is required as the barbs constantly graze on the abundant biofilm growing on the driftwood resulting in a very thick slick of biofilm on the water’s surface in the absence of a skimmer. Filtration is provided by a Fluval FX6, and extra current is provided by a powerhead placed at the opposite end of the tank to send water back toward the filter intake. Spawning: Catching fish in this heavily aquascaped setup would be nigh impossible, so spawning in situ is de rigueur . From time-to-time Odessa fry have appeared but to date only one has survived to become a subadult. The others are snacked on by the Clown Barbs which easily slurp up juveniles. So, for spawning and raising fry in numbers to be successful, capture and removal of the eggs are a must. After deep gravel siphoning and tank cleaning, accompanied by thoroughly rinsing filter media and a series of increasingly large water changes, two spawning baskets were prepared (the usual Ikea shoebox filled with marbles 2-3 layers deep, overlaid with plastic egg crate, overlaid by needlepoint canvas, overlaid by green synthetic spawning mops) and placed in the center of the tank. Odessa Barbs spawn after lights on under bright light. In good tank conditions, fully adult males are colored up black and crimson red virtually all the time. When spawning, the males chase each other in whirling displays of prowess. No one seems to get injured apart from the occasional scrape from bumping into driftwood. Then they try to lure the females into the spawning basket. Spawning is the typical side-by-side clutch of barbs without inversion. Because there is a surplus of males relative to females, it can be hard for a pair to settle long enough to successfully spawn in the baskets. There have been many failed attempts to collect the eggs. On 10/25-26/2019, there was success at last. The trick seemed to be leaving the spawning baskets in for 48 hours giving the barbs two full days to settle down enough for pairs to sneak in and drop eggs. On 10/26/2019, I pulled >100 eggs from the two baskets and placed them in a large, unheated Kritter Keeper with small box filter. The entire volume of this hatching box was filled with loose java moss and placed on a dark brown towel which was then wrapped around the bottom of the tank so that the bottom of the tank would be relatively dark and the top would have subdued, ambient lighting. The water temperature is 70oF. Raising Fry: The fry began to hatch about 3 days later. By October 29 two larval fish were spotted. By November 3 at least six, and by November 5 at least fifteen were free-swimming. During the first week after they became free-swimming, the fry were fed twice a day, once with a mixture of rotifers and euglena, and once with a slurry of vinegar eels, microworms, and both 5-50 and 50-100 micron Golden Pearls. Week 2 the above diet was supplemented with paramecium.
  • Moenkhausia pittieri (Diamond Tetra) Spawning Report Submitted by Patchin Crandall Curtis Background: The diamond tetra is found in shallow, vegetated parts of Lake Valencia, as well as in several slow-moving tributaries. Lake Valencia and its watershed is situated between two picturesque mountain ranges in Venezuela. Lake temperatures are tropical varying from 75o – 82oF. The lake surface is at an altitude of 410 m (1,350 ft), the maximum depth is 39 m, and the mean depth 18 m. The lake has a number of small islands, some inhabited. Lake Valencia suffers from algal blooms caused by continual influx of untreated wastewater from the surrounding urban, agricultural, and industrial land uses. This contributes to ongoing eutrophication, contamination, and salinization of the lake negatively impacting this gorgeous community fish. Colony: Purchased pond-raised males from Matt Chambers on 1/6/2018 and wild-caught females from the Wet Spot on 4/17/2019. The current colony consists of 5 males and 3 females. They are kept at 76oF. I have experienced losses when water temperatures were consistently higher than 78oF and thus believe that they enjoy better health when maintained at the lower end of their reported temperature range. The wild-caught females were juveniles when the fish arrived in April. They were grown out on a diet of Repashy Igapo Explorer and Soilent Green, and New Life Spectrum, Cobalt, and North Fin brand community pellets. At least twice a week they were fed a variety of frozen foods. When a single fry somehow survived in a community tank with other tetras, I decided it was time to undertake some controlled spawning experiments. Tank Set-Up & Spawning: On 9/15/2019 a 20L tank was prepared with a coarse gravel bottom to catch eggs (CaribSea Joe’s Creek), 2 pieces of Malaysian driftwood with Christmas moss attached with black silicone hairbands, and spawning mops dangling down in the corners suspended from Styrofoam floats to simulate the overhang from vegetation at water’s edge. A 50% water change was performed with 50/50 tap water/RO mix. Flourish fertilizer was added to help establish the java moss, and Tetra Black Water Extract was added to stain the water and provide tannins. Water temperature was set at 77oF. In the evening, the fish were netted out of the community tank and placed in the 20L. The next morning, a catalpa leaf and an alder cone were added to the tank along with a disk of Repashy Igapo Explorer. The lights were turned off and the fish took refuge in the darkened corners of the tank underneath the spawning mops where they remained hidden and inactive. After waiting 15 minutes, I turned off the air supply thereby cutting off the current. The fish then moved into the center of the tank and started to swim around to investigate their surroundings but after 2 hours became inactive again, so I turned the air back on adjusting the flow to be moderately slow. They perked back up again, with males lazily circling each other but no overt spawning behavior. After a few days of heavy feeding, the males appeared to display to each other but I never saw a direct spawn with a female. On 10/1/2019 the Diamond Tetras were removed to repurpose the tank for quarantining Croaking Gouramis for the Spring All-Day Auction, and then some newly purchased Sharp-Nosed Chocolate Gouramis. The tank was thoroughly siphoned and cleaned a couple of times between fish shipments. At this point, my working assumption was that any eggs deposited by the Diamond Tetras had probably been either eaten or siphoned out, or the fry eaten by the Gouramis. Raising Fry: Then, on 10/18/2019 after feeding the Chocolate Gouramis heavily on newly hatched BBS, I noticed a bunch of relatively large, plain, silver fry with full guts that looked near to bursting. The first day I could just see 6 or so, the next day 8, and then 12 the next. They hide very effectively in the floating plants and among the driftwood and java moss. They are already quite large ranging from 5 mm to 1 cm in length. Their maximum possible age is 5 weeks old, so the fry must be very fast-growing compared to Blue Emperor Tetras which would take at least 12 weeks to reach a similar size. On 11/1/2019 the tank was thoroughly cleaned and the fry placed in a clear container to be photographed. The fry are somewhere in the range of 4-6 weeks. They may be from a single spawn or multiple spawns sometime during the last 2 weeks of September.
  • Video Journal Species Mikrogeophagus Ramirezi German Blue Ram (Electric Blue Male & Golden Female) Reproduction Method of Reproduction: Egg Layer Number and Gender Distribution of Parents: 1 Male (Electric Blue), 1 Female (Golden) Pair Origin of Parents: LFS (source unknown) Approximate number of fry: Originally hatched ca. 75 Date of Birth: Free Swimming 18 September 2019 Approx. Number of Fry at 30 Days: ca. 45 Aquarium Conditions Breeding Tank: pH — 7.5 GH —5 drops / ca. 90 ppm KH — 2 drops / ca. 35 ppm Temperature: 81 degrees Fahrenheit Average Nitrate: 20 ppm Aquarium Size: 29 gal; in inches, 30.25” wide x 12.5” deep x 18.75” high Water Source: town / city water Water Changes: 60% every 2 weeks Filtration System: Hang-on-back, Emperor 280 (with bio wheel) Holding / Fry Tank: pH — 6.3 (50 % R.O. water added daily) GH — (tests were difficult to read) 5 drops / 90 ppm KH — (tests were difficult to read) 5 drops / 90 ppm Temperature: 81 degrees Fahrenheit (same as 29 gal, Fry Container suspended in Tank) Average Nitrate: 25-30 ppm Aquarium Size: Lee’s Large Specimen Container; in inches, 7” wide x 3.25” deep x 6” high Water Source: R.O. bottled water Water Changes: 50% daily Filtration System: none; in future, we plan to add a micro sponge filter to cycle the container) Decor & Environment (Spawning Tank) Live Plants: Heavily planted tank featuring: dwarf baby tears, rotala indica, ludwigia ovalis, ludwigia repens, red melon swords, wisteria, bronze crypts, java moss (Spawning Tank) Caves or Similar Hiding Places: one small plastic cave, and several salt-and-pepper rocks rams prefer to lay eggs on (Spawning Tank) Substrate: Eco-complete black substrate Lighting Type and Timing: One blue coral T-12 (?) fluorescent with LED strip lighting (used ca. 12 hrs / day), and additional LED utility light (used for only about 4 hrs x day) (Fry Container) Live Plants: small Water Lettuce sprouts (Fry Container) Caves or similar hiding Places: none, bare bottom (Fry Container) Substrate: none (Fry Container) MISC: Several snails added to process some waste, and lightly running air stone suspended inside Feeding Food Fed to Parents and How Often: Fluval Bug Bites, Cobalt Fry Minis, Hikari Freeze-dried BBS, Live BBS (2x / day) Food Fed to Fry and How Often: Live baby brine shrimp, Sera-micron (2x / day) Photographs Comments & Additional Information Mikrogeophagus Ramirezi, best known as the “German Blue Ram,” are the fish that really got us into breeding. Our first attempt last year ended in failure. But then we were able to raise 7 fry from a second batch to maturity. One major goal has been to raise a BAP viable batch of 10 or more. In brief, we set up the decor so that the rams will spawn on a small rock which is then removed to a separate container with a suspended air stone to “tumble” the water over the eggs. Between 1/2 to 1 ml. of Hydrogen Peroxide (H2O2) is added 1x every 12 hours, for just two doses to fight off fungus. The fry hatch in ca. 2-3 days, seen as wigglers. Once they eat through their yolk sack and are free-swimming, the challenge begins. Sometimes a male does not properly fertilize the eggs. Another time the eggs were laid in an area too difficult to “pull” in order to hatch. With this pair - an Electric Blue Male, and a Golden Female - their first batch did not survive past three weeks. We tried feeding on hard-boiled egg-yolk and Sera micron, but without an early transition to live food, they did not grow properly. With this (submitted) batch, we determined to move them over to baby brine shrimp earlier. This has made all of the difference in survival rate. Furthermore, we have since been able to successfully move more batches over the two-week threshold with this feeding plan. We feed the rams 2x / day, feeding BBS and a light dose of Sera-Micron mixed in water. Daily vigilance is essential with Ram fry. We carefully siphon off all waste and uneaten food off the bottom, and draw out 50% of the container water. This is replaced by R.O. water that has been suspended in the tank to reach tank-temperature (ca. 81 degrees Fahrenheit). We plan to transition these small fry first to a “well-seasoned” 5.5. gal aquarium containing a fair amount of algae and plants to grow out for a month or so. From there, we have a 20 gallon long that will be the larger ram-colony grow out tank until the rams are ready to be culled, moved on to our LFS, or selected for ongoing breeding projects. Three other batches were also grown in this period. Another small one from the same parents had only 6 fry survive. Two other batches from 2nd generation GBR born in our water had 4 fry and ca. 50 fry respectively. Apart from the first few days where fry are free swimming and need food that they can consume, the crucial time frame for survival is the 2-3 week point. In this period, the rams tend to crash with just a few survivors — or en masse — they tend to press through and survive as a larger group. Water quality is crucial, as any buildup of Ammonia or Nitrate leads to early fatalities. It is difficult to keep the containers fully cycled with this approach. Nitrite tends to read higher than preferable. In the future, we plan to implement micro-sponge filters in the Specimen Containers to cycle them once the fry are large enough to avoid being hurt.

Potomac Valley Aquarium Society

PO Box 664

Merrifield, VA 22116

©2019 by Potomac Valley Aquarium Society, Inc.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter